How is Prior Income Determined in Disability Insurance Policies?
When it comes to calculating partial disability benefits, there is no uniform calculation across the board and formulas can vary widely by policy. Generally speaking, the first step in the calculations involves evaluating the amount you were making before your disability—referred to as “Prior Income” or “Prior Earnings” in most policies. However, how this number is determined can vary by company and even be different in policies issued by the same company.
Some common scenarios used to calculate prior income include:
Your average monthly income for either the last 24 calendar months just prior to the date on which You became Disabled, or for the two calendar years with the highest earnings in the three calendar years just prior to the date on which You became Disabled, whichever is greater. (from a Guardian policy)
“The sum of Your highest annual earnings for any two full tax years within the three full years preceding the day Your Disability began, divided by 24”. (from a Standard policy)
“The greater of: (a) Your average Monthly Earnings for the year just before Your Disability began; or (b) Your highest average Monthly Earnings for any 2 successive years during the 5 year period just before Your Disability began.” (from a Unum policy)
“The greater of: the average monthly income earned and received for the last 12 months before the start of Disability; or the average monthly income earned and received for the last 24 months before the start of Disability; or the average monthly income earned and received for the highest consecutive 24 months during the 60 months prior to Disability.” (from a MassMutual policy)
As you can see, different policies have different lookback periods and sometimes have more than one way to reach a prior income number. At the time of filing a claim, companies will request financial documents such as tax returns, Profit and Loss statements, and paystubs to reach a prior income number.
These calculations can be involved and complex, particularly when it comes to determine what should and should not count as “earned income.” If you are filing a disability claim and feel like your insurance company has not fairly calculated your prior earnings, it is a good idea to speak with a disability insurance attorney and have them review the disability companies calculations to ensure that the number was accurately determined according to the terms of your policy.
